The Changing World and Its Controversies
The world has changed significantly in recent years. Some view these changes as progress, while others see them as a setback. One such case involves Pamela Richard, a Kansas teacher who stood firm in her beliefs, even at the risk of suspension.
Pamela Richard’s Stand
At the time, Richard was working at Geary County Schools in Kansas. She was suspended for three days after refusing to use a student’s preferred pronouns. Richard clarified the issue, stating she was suspended “for addressing a biologically female student by the student’s legal and enrolled last name.”
The Disagreement
A school counselor had informed Richard that one of her students preferred to use a different first name and wanted to be referred to as a different gender. However, the student was biologically female. To avoid using the student’s preferred name, Richard referred to her as “Miss [legal/enrolled last name],” which she felt was a fair compromise. Unfortunately, this approach did not resolve the issue.
Suspension and the Policy Conflict
Richard was eventually suspended. The school’s policy stated that employees should make an effort to use the pronouns a student requested. Richard, however, felt the policy violated her conscience.
Legal Action and Religious Beliefs
Richard filed a lawsuit, citing her Christian beliefs. According to the lawsuit, “Ms. Richard believes that God created human beings as either male or female… and that this sex is fixed from conception, regardless of individual feelings or desires.”
Court Victory and $95,000 Award
In May, Richard took her case to federal court and won a $95,000 settlement. Her attorney explained that the decision allowed her to “speak without violating her conscience.” Additionally, Richard was permitted to avoid using pronouns that didn’t align with a student’s biological sex. The court ruled against the school’s policy that prohibited staff from disclosing students’ preferred names or pronouns to their parents.
School’s Silence
Since the lawsuit, the school has not issued any comments regarding the case.