Snow still covers the spot where Alex Jeffrey Pretti fell, now buried beneath flowers, candles, and hand-lettered signs asking why a healer died in a federal operation he wasn’t the target of. To his patients, he was the calm voice in the ICU at 3 a.m. To his family, he was the quiet son who hiked with his dog and argued that real patriotism meant showing up for people without power.

Now his name is chanted at vigils as investigators sift through body-camera footage and bystander videos, trying to reconstruct the seconds between raised voices and a fatal shot. Officials urge patience; the community demands clarity. Somewhere between those positions is a family replaying the final frames of a blurry recording, searching for the moment when a citizen, a nurse, and a protester became a symbol—and a question no one can yet answer.