The American Idol season 23 finale on May 18, 2025, saw Jamal Roberts crowned the winner, but his victory sparked a flood of criticism. Many fans expressed disappointment, arguing that runner-up John Foster should have won.

Social media was filled with comments like “John was robbed” and “Another rigged season.” Some viewers even pledged not to watch the show again due to the result.

Along with the controversy over the winner, Carrie Underwood’s judging during the season also drew criticism. Many fans questioned her harsh critiques of Jamal Roberts and her apparent bias. Some even called for her to be replaced as a judge. Despite the backlash, there were defenders of Underwood, and some fans hoped she would return in the future.

The finale also saw eliminations of Thunderstorm Artis and Slater Nalley, while Roberts, Foster, and Breanna Nix made it to the final three. The season ended with divided opinions, as viewers debated both the winner and the judges’ performance.