Bad Bunny’s official halftime show isn’t just a booking; it’s a statement about what the NFL believes America is becoming. A Puerto Rican superstar rapping and singing in Spanish on the biggest stage in U.S. sports signals confidence in a multilingual, borderless pop culture. For millions, it feels natural, overdue, even thrilling. For others, it feels like something familiar has slipped away without their consent.

Turning Point USA’s “All American Halftime Show” exists for that second group. Kid Rock and a slate of country acts promise guitars, flags, and a vision of America where the volume is high but the boundaries are clear. The clash isn’t really about setlists; it’s about belonging. In the end, most people will still just watch the game. But the memory that lingers will be which soundtrack felt like theirs—and which one suddenly didn’t.