Jessica Tarlov, the outspoken liberal voice on Fox News’ The Five, is facing major backlash after a fiery on-air exchange with military veteran and co-host Joey Jones and it’s what she said in the heat of the moment that has viewers stunned.

During a panel discussion on gun control following this week’s tragic Minnesota church shooting, the conversation took a deeply personal turn and ended with Tarlov making a remark many fans are calling “disgusting” and “beyond the pale.”

“Now you’ve played the leg card”

As Joey Jones, a retired Marine Corps bomb technician who lost both legs in Afghanistan, made a passionate case against sweeping gun bans, Tarlov interrupted with a pointed question: “If your kid was one of that four percent, I think you’d be singing a different tune.”

Jones began to respond calmly, “Yeah, but my kid isn’t—”, when Tarlov cut him off with a sarcastic, “Oh, so lucky you!”

What came next stunned even longtime viewers.

“I’ll go to bed tonight and thank God on my knees that don’t exist anymore that my child is still alive,” Jones said, turning directly to the camera.

Tarlov’s response? “Well, now you’ve played the leg card, and I can say no more.”

The moment landed like a grenade across social media.

“Reprehensible” and “egregious”: Viewers call for consequences

Viewers immediately lit up X and Facebook with furious reactions.

One user wrote: “She’s reprehensible. Fox will never get rid of her.” And many others called for her to be fired immediately, saying an apology wouldn’t be enough.

One X user wrote, “My hats off to you Joey Jones for that magnificent takedown… And her telling you you’re ‘playing the leg card’ should get her booted permanently from The Five.”

Through it all, Joey Jones kept his grace

Amid the backlash, fans have rallied around Joey Jones for handling the situation with dignity and clarity, despite the deeply personal nature of the jab.

Jones, who often speaks about the strength he’s found after his injury, has become one of Fox News’ most respected voices on both military affairs and policy. And moments like this, where he responds with poise, not anger, only reinforce that reputation.

One thing is certain: Joey Jones didn’t need to “play the leg card.” His response alone showed why so many viewers see him as one of the most respected voices at Fox News.